Classic Cookie Menu
Classic Cookies
These classic favorites get a gourmet upgrade. Sold as Singles, 6 Packs, Baker's Dozen, or Party Packs (24 ct)
Brown Butter Heath Chip
Soft baked and chewy, these cookies have our signature vanilla forward cookie base and are filled and topped with gooey semi-sweet chocolate chips and bits of toffee.
Single
$3
6 Pack
$16
Baker's Dozen
$30
Party Pack (24 ct)
$54
Chewy Oatmeal Raisin
Soft baked and gently spiced, these chewy oatmeal cookies are a family favorite.
Single
$3
6 Pack
$16
Baker's Dozen
$30
Party Pack (24 ct)
$54
Chocolate Crinkle
Soft and gooey chocolate inside, crinkly powdered sugar outside makes this a traditional holiday favorite.
Single
$3
6 Pack
$16
Baker's Dozen
$30
Party Pack (24 ct)
$54
Chocolate Crinkle Cherry Blossom
Soft and gooey chocolate inside, crinkly powdered sugar outside, topped with a cherry filled Hershey Kiss fresh out of the oven for a new spin on an old favorite.
Single
$3
6 Pack
$16
Baker's Dozen
$30
Party Pack (24 ct)
$54
Classic No Bakes
Vintage chocolate and peanut butter no bake recipe
Single
$3
6 Pack
$16
Baker's Dozen
$30
Party Pack (24 ct)
$54
Death By Chocolate
Thick and gooey, these cookies have a double chocolate cookie base with milk and white chocolate chips. The ultimate decadent treat for chocolate lovers.
Single
$3
6 Pack
$16
Baker's Dozen
$30
Party Pack (24 ct)
$54
Mini M&M Monster Cookie
Soft baked and chewy, these cookies have our signature vanilla forward cookie base and are filled and topped with semi-sweet chocolate chips and mini M&M candies.
Single
$3
6 Pack
$16
Baker's Dozen
$30
Party Pack (24 ct)
$54
OG Chocolate Chunk
Soft baked and chewy, these cookies have our signature vanilla forward cookie base and are filled and topped with gooey semi-sweet chocolate chunks and chips. This recipe is what started it all.
Single
$3
6 Pack
$16
Baker's Dozen
$30
Party Pack (24 ct)
$54
Peanut Butter Blossoms
Rich, thick, and chewy with a lightly crisp edge- these cookies are loaded with creamy peanut butter then topped with a Hershey Kiss fresh out of the oven.
Single
$3
6 Pack
$16
Baker's Dozen
$30
Party Pack (24 ct)
$54
Peanut Butter Lover's
Rich, thick, and chewy with a lightly crisp edge- these XL cookies are loaded with creamy peanut butter, sugar coated & crosshatched for a classic finish.
Single
$3
6 Pack
$16
Baker's Dozen
$30
Party Pack (24 ct)
$54
Reese's Pieces Monster Cookie
Soft baked and chewy, these cookies have our signature vanilla forward cookie base and are filled and topped with semi-sweet chocolate chips, Reese’s Pieces© candies, and mini Reese’s© cups
Single
$3
6 Pack
$16
Baker's Dozen
$30
Party Pack (24 ct)
$54
Salted Caramel No Bakes
A modern twist on a classic no bake cookie recipe featuring mini chocolate chips and Heath toffee bits in a caramel no bake cookie base.
Single
$3
6 Pack
$16
Baker's Dozen
$30
Party Pack (24 ct)
$54
Snickerdoodle
Soft and pillowy with a tender center, this XL Snickerdoodle get a double dip in cinnamon sugar for maximum indulgence.
Single
$3
6 Pack
$16
Baker's Dozen
$30
Party Pack (24 ct)
$54
White Chocolate Macadamia
Soft baked and chewy, these cookies have our signature vanilla forward cookie base and are filled and topped with white chocolate & macadamia nuts.
Single
$3
6 Pack
$16
Baker's Dozen
$30
Party Pack (24 ct)
$54
Holiday Sampler Gift Boxes
Choose from one of our Signature Sampler boxes or build your own custom dozen. Each cookie comes individually wrapped and labeled before being packed in a holiday themed cookie box and shrink wrapped to ensure freshness. Blank gift tag included.
Chocoholic's Signature Sampler Box
Includes 4 Death By Chocolate Cookies, 4 OG Chocolate Chunk & 4 Chocolate Crinkle Cookies for the ultimate Chocoholic Sampler.
$35
Family Favorite's Signature Sampler Box
Includes 4 OG Chocolate Chunk Cookies, 4 Snickerdoodle Cookies & 4 Chewy Oatmeal Raisin Cookies. A little somethin' for everyone.
$35
Peanut Butter Lover's Signature Sampler Box
Includes 4 Peanut Butter Lover's cookies, 4 Peanut Butter Blossoms & 4 Reese's Monster Cookies for the ultimate peanut butter lover's sampler.
$35
Custom Halfsies Box
Choose 2 of our gourmet XL cookie recipes to build a half & half dozen.
$35
Custom Sampler Box
Choose from our Classic Cookie menu to build your perfect dozen.
$35
